2003

1) Elephant
2) Lost In Translation 
3) Return Of The King
4) Kill Bill: Volume One
5) Mystic River
6) The Magdalene Sisters
7) City Of God
8) 21 Grams
9) Capturing The Friedmans
10) Triplets of Belleville

Runners-Up:

Finding Nemo, The Station Agent, To Be and To Have, School of Rock, 28 Days Later, Spellbound, Irreversible, Gerry, Swimming Pool, House of Sand and Fog, Dirty Pretty Things, Matchstick Men, Bad Santa, Les Invasions Barbares, Shattered Glass, Dark Blue, Phone Booth, A Mighty Wind