We finally got one: an A+ CinemaScore that didn't go to a concert film or a faith-based movie.
I'm not exaggerating. For the past four years, the very rare “A+” has basically gone to two kinds of films: faith-based releases, most of them from Angel Studios, and music docs from Taylor Swift, Beyoncé and Elvis. Regular movies, the kind made for a broad audience, haven't been part of it.
Now Peter Farrelly's “I Play Rocky” has broken that spell. If you can believe it, this is actually Farrelly's second A+ CinemaScore, after “Green Book” in 2018, and we all remember how that one ended. If there was any doubt that this would get nominated for Best Picture, I think it was wiped away tonight. Exit polls don't decide the Oscars, but an A+ tells you word of mouth is about to take over, and that kind of momentum tends to get noticed in late November.
None of this surprises me. I've been saying for months that this is the crowd-pleaser of the season. Fall festival audiences embraced it wholeheartedly, even as a certain contingent of critics seemed determined to knock it down.
No, really, set your highbrow standards aside. “I Play Rocky” is a highly entertaining movie, the kind of old-school entertainment that barely gets made anymore, with an irresistible story at its center. It's an underdog tale about the making of the ultimate underdog movie, and you know what? It actually works.
“I Play Rocky” tells how a broke, unknown Sylvester Stallone (Anthony Ippolito, who is terrific) refused to sell his script unless he got to play Rocky Balboa. He turned down the kind of money that would have set him up for life. It's not only infectiously dramatic but also a very funny movie, and audiences have clearly fallen for it.
It helps that Stallone, who initially shrugged the film off and even complained that he wasn't consulted on it, has now come out and given it his seal of approval: “I was incredibly skeptical about ‘I Play Rocky,’ but it's so authentic… It was literally history repeating itself, and it was so surreal.”
This is a movie that deserves to be embraced by an audience. It looks like it's getting exactly that.
If you can believe it, this is actually Peter Farrelly's second A+ CinemaScore, after “Green Book” in 2018, and we all remember how that one ended. Buckle up, folks — word of mouth is starting to spread.