Back in 2019, I reported on the messy production of James Gray's "Ad Astra." I was told that the version in theaters was absolutely not Gray's. There were reshoots he didn't sign off on, voiceover narration added late, and Liv Tyler flashbacks put in, reportedly at the insistence of Brad Pitt, who was also a producer.
Gray has slowly been confirming most of this over the years. In 2022 he called the narration "stupid" and said it wasn't his choice. This year, he complained that the film was "taken away" from him.
Today he went further. In a Reddit AMA, Gray gave his most detailed description yet of what his version actually is:
My cut, which is very weird to say this because it's usually not the case, but my cut of that film was actually 12 minutes shorter. This is somewhat unheard of, but is the case for “Ad Astra.” What I would do is I would have less narration.
He kept going:
In my cut, there was more Ruth Negga and more Donald Sutherland, and the ending was different. The ending just ended with him being led out of the capsule, out of focus, and collapsing. There were also some music differences. The opening and closing of the film used Wagner's overture to Parsifal, for example."
Let's go through it.
Firstly, the cast. Ruth Negga's Helen was one of the more intriguing characters in the movie, and she barely gets any screen time in the theatrical cut. Donald Sutherland's Colonel Pruitt leaves the film far too early. Restoring their footage would also mean something more now that Sutherland is gone. He died in 2024.
Secondly, and most interesting, is the ending. The theatrical version ends with McBride back on Earth, emotionally exhausted, with something like closure. Gray's ending stops much earlier: Pitt being led out of the capsule, out of focus, collapsing. It's far bleaker and more ambiguous, and it fits Gray’s style much better. It sounds like Fox wanted a warmer ending.
Then there's the Wagner. Gray would open and close the film with the "Parsifal" prelude, a piece that, from what I've read, is about a wounded man and a long search for redemption, which basically describes the core of "Ad Astra."
As for what a director's cut would look like, Gray already has a game plan:
So there were many differences, and I think it would be quite a different movie. Starting with just restoring some of the footage of Ruth Negga and Donald Sutherland and losing some of the stuff I felt was unnecessary.
I've always thought there was a great film buried inside “Ad Astra.” You could feel two competing visions crashing against each other. It was Gray's most expensive movie at around $80M before reshoots, and it made only about $50M domestically. I just can’t imagine a scenario where Disney would actually fund a director's cut. The only way I can see Gray's shorter version ever seeing the light of day would be via Criterion-style release, and not totally implausible.
I've always thought there was a great film buried inside “Ad Astra.” You could feel two competing visions crashing against each other. James Gray knows that. He wants a director’s cut.