"Polly Pocket" has been in development for five years. It has now lost its original director and its original star.
According to Deadline, Lili Reinhart is in talks to star in and executive produce Amazon/MGM Studios and Mattel Studios' "Polly Pocket," following Lily Collins' departure from the project a while ago due to a scheduling conflict.
Ah, the good old “scheduling conflict.” Collins had been attached since day one. That goes back to June 2021, when Lena Dunham was set to write and direct, with Collins playing the title role. Dunham left later over creative differences, and as I wrote back in June, Clea DuVall took over the director's chair. Now the lead is gone too. Is anything left of the original package besides the title? The script is by "Sweethearts" scribes Jordan Weiss and Dan Brier.
Casting Reinhart makes sense, at least on paper. Amazon is keeping it in the family. She most recently headlined "The Love Hypothesis" for Amazon/MGM Studios, which debuted at #2 on Nielsen's movies chart. She's 30 and has been quietly building a post-"Riverdale" career. Since the show ended she's done the mystery thriller "American Sweatshop" and the Mubi miniseries "Hal & Harper", the latter being Cooper Raiff's terrific little show. She's a proven streaming draw, which tells you how Amazon sees this movie.
That's the key detail here. Unlike "Barbie," "Polly Pocket" is being made for streaming, not theatrical release. Whatever Mattel tells its shareholders, this isn't being positioned as the next billion-dollar phenomenon. It's Prime Video content with a nostalgic toy brand slapped on top.
The timeline is also a little murky. In June, reports said the film was being fast-tracked to start production this October in Atlanta. That clearly didn't happen. One production listing now has it filming in Toronto, between February 9 and April 20, 2027.
Meanwhile, the rest of Mattel's slate keeps growing: Vin Diesel's "Rock 'Em Sock 'Em Robots," still without a completed script or director, and M. Night Shyamalan's "Magic 8 Ball." I remain skeptical that most of these will turn out to be anything more than glorified product placement. Still, DuVall made “The Intervention,” and "Happiest Season" work, so maybe she can pull off a charming little streaming comedy here. We'll see.
Exactly one year ago, Macaulay Culkin had a pitch for a legacy "Home Alone" sequel, and now it looks like Disney is making it happen, with Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg.