David Fincher has always been fascinated by filmmaking technology, and that isn't changing now that "The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth" is facing accusations of using generative AI.
There is context, though. Back in March, Bloomberg reported that Fincher had used tech from InterPositive, Ben Affleck's AI company, on an upcoming Brad Pitt film. It can only be ‘Cliff Booth.’ Netflix then bought the company in a deal reportedly worth up to $600M.
Speaking to the Los Angeles Times, Fincher made it clear he has little patience for people who want filmmaking frozen in time. "I'm not a Luddite, so I don't fear the unknown," he said. He pointed out that people have been painting for something like 40,000 years, while cinema is barely a century old. So why would we stop iterating now? Being able to change the color of an actor's eyes with a click "exists," he said. "Should we not use it?"
Now, about the controversy. Since the film's press screenings, screenshots and alleged visual glitches from "Cliff Booth" have been all over social media. Giovanni Lago flagged apparent AI use in several sequences in his Next Best Picture review, and that kickstarted the storm. Netflix hasn't confirmed or addressed any of it.
Over at The Playlist, they point to two moments. The first is an early montage of stunt work by Scott Caan's character, which includes a few fleeting images that don't quite look right. The second is a montage that puts Elizabeth Debicki on a red carpet next to classic Hollywood stars. He's careful to say a gut feeling isn't proof, and he's right. Online sleuthing isn't proof either.
Fincher has also been open about using AI before. He told Entertainment Weekly last year that AI tools helped clean up imperfections in the 4K restoration of "Se7en." The recent "Fight Club" restoration took heat for digital alterations too, although AI involvement there hasn't been confirmed. Back in 2023, he told British GQ that AI had creative possibilities, while doubting it could ever replicate what a human artist brings.
Patrick Tomasso's tweet about walking out of ‘Cliff Booth’ "completely gutted" by “some of the most blatant and egregious AI use I've ever seen in a studio film" has been viewed almost a million times. Look, I respect the passion, but I have to push back. If the AI were that blatant, why aren't more critics talking about it in their reviews? I sure didn't notice anything that took me out of the movie. More importantly, should a few seconds of possibly generated imagery in a montage really stop you from calling a film great?
Fincher has been more fascinated by digital tools than almost any other auteur. He's been pushing the medium forward since "Zodiac," and he went even further with "Benjamin Button." Did the AI in "Cliff Booth" bother me? I can't say I noticed any moments blatant enough to have me stand up, point at the screen and yell, "AI!" It didn't take me out of the movie.
Still, you can bet top dollar this is going to keep coming up. Every odd-looking frame is going to get screenshotted, slowed down and picked apart. Whether you like it or not, Fincher supposedly using AI is a big deal. No filmmaker as well respected as him has used it until now, and there will only be more coming. Darren Aronofsky's next film might have AI. George Miller, who used it on "Furiosa," might double down on it to make the next "Mad Max," currently in limbo, cheaper and more enticing for a major studio to take on. There have also been whispers that Michael Mann will use AI to de-age some of his actors on "Heat 2." George Lucas recently said it's "the future of cinema."
Many people are now saying they won't see ‘Cliff Booth’ because it used the technology, a boycott is happening in certain film circles, and that Fincher has sold out. They don't even care whether it's a good movie (which it is). What do you make of this?
Look at who it just beat. Nolan's "The Odyssey" made $17.6M in previews on its way to a $123.5M opening. "Wicked" did $19.2M in previews and opened to $112.5M. ‘Sunrise on the Reaping’ has a real shot at $120M.