How do you even begin to explain "Madden"?
I watched it last night, and I'm still not sure how this movie got made. Somebody at Amazon gave David O. Russell a reported $75M, plus Nicolas Cage in a fat suit and Christian Bale in full prosthetics. Then they let him make a 110-minute John Madden biopic that plays like a fever dream.
I'm fascinated by it. "Madden" is very watchable in a what-the-hell-am-I-watching way. You can't look away from it, much like you can't look away from a train wreck. I get why critics are calling for Razzies, but shouldn't the Razzies be saved for dull movies? "Madden" is certainly not one of those.
Nicolas Cage plays John Madden like a cartoon. He's practically a Looney Tunes character. This is Cage going full Kabuki, and I mean that literally. He has long described his acting style as "Western Kabuki," a heightened, theatrical approach that throws naturalism out the window. Here it's being applied to a real, beloved man whom millions of Americans know. Every line reading feels like a choice, and almost none of them feel like Madden. The accent doesn't sound like him either. And yet you can't stop watching, because Cage is fully committed to it.
I'm almost tempted to let this film off the hook as a mockumentary, except it isn't one. Characters talk to the camera in interview-style setups, decades go by without you even realizing it (the wigs are your only clue), and then the movie veers into something more impressionistic. Actually, that's a good way to describe "Madden": impressionistic. That's always been Russell's mode, really. "American Hustle" and "Silver Linings Playbook" were driven more by rhythm and improv energy than by plot. "Madden" just takes that approach to an unhinged extreme. There's one scene where Bale's character explains N.W.A. to Madden. I kid you not. According to Bale, it was all ad-libbed and wasn't in the script. I'm not surprised.
Shane Gillis is also in this movie. You know, the same guy whose "SNL" monologue just a few weeks ago, in which he described women who wear tight neon shorts at the gym as "whores," turned him into public enemy numero uno online. He plays Vince McGarry, a drunken Raiders superfan and former neighbor of Madden's. The script has him come back again and again to remind Madden who he is. He's also used for a jump scare. Former NFL player Marshawn Lynch plays an EA programmer in goofy glasses. John Mulaney is Trip Hawkins, and at least he knows exactly what kind of movie he's in. Every gesture and line delivery from Mulaney is exaggerated.
Here's the thing, though. I couldn't stop watching. I kept asking myself, why am I not turning this movie off? At its core, "Madden" is a strange bromance between Cage's lovable lug of a coach and Bale's strident Davis. They both ham it up so hard that it seems like they're trying to out-weird each other. How can a movie like that not be watchable? Every scene leaves you wondering what the hell Russell, Cage and Bale were thinking.
Is "Madden" a good movie? Ah, therein lies the ultimate question. I don't think so? At least not in any conventional sense. The structure is a mess, the tone changes from scene to scene, and Cage's performance will be ridiculed for years. And yet I love how this movie actually exists. There's something oddly admirable about a $75M studio biopic this willing to ignore every rule of the genre. "Madden" is going to stick around, whether Russell meant it that way or not.
Is "Madden" a good movie? Ah, therein lies the ultimate question. I don't think so? At least not in any conventional sense. And yet I love how this movie actually exists.