Clayton Davis is the latest addition to the Variety film section and his first column today, titled “How I’ll Be Predicting the Oscars for Variety,” was not a good start for a section of online onlookers. Davis raised more than a few eyebrows, despite the piece being a well-written, positive, and amicable intro to readers, due to his admittance that a) he has never seen “Casablanca” and b) considers his top three films of all-time to be “Dead Poets Society,” “Forrest Gump” and “Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back”.
I like Clayton, but he seems to represent this new trend of film journalism which implies that you don’t necessarily need a firm grasp of movie history to write about it. How do you pursue a living as a film writer, and predicting the Oscars, without having seen “Casablanca”? Some think it’s not an issue, others most definitely do. I’m not trying to judge here, no, really, I’m not, I have met countless millennial film critics who have never even seen “Citizen Kane,” and/or “Vertigo,” so there are plenty of Clayton Davis’ out there and maybe that’s a problem.
It’s not like seeing any of these films should be seen as an actual legitimate commitment problem. TCM manages to squeeze in airings of these three classics on a monthly basis. Then again, how can you live as a film writer without the memory of Bogart, Bergman, Henreid, Rains, Lorre, and Greenstreet hanging at Rick’s Cafe? Suffice to say, it takes a lot of chutzpah for a Variety columnist to say “I’ve never seen “Casablanca.” At least Davis isn’t hiding it. Kudos.
Roger Ebert’s advice to younger film critics
The man doesn't stop. James Gunn has confirmed he's already hard at work writing his next film, even as ‘Man of Tomorrow’ makes its way toward theaters next summer.