The embargo has finally lifted on ‘Cliff Booth,’ and I’ll get to my thoughts in a second. First off, don’t listen to the reviews. I feel like, when this project was first announced, many were expecting an Oscar contender to emerge from this Fincher-Tarantino marriage, but that’s not what this movie is about.
You know what it is instead? Two good friends, both of whom happen to be among the best filmmakers alive, having a great time making a movie. How can you possibly resist that? So far, ‘Cliff Booth’ sits at 68 on Metacritic and 85% on Rotten Tomatoes. That’s not bad, right? Still, I think that shortchanges what is certainly one of the year’s best films.
Look, I'll get this out of the way first. ‘Cliff Booth’ is not "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood." It doesn't have that film's masterful set pieces, the slow-burn Spahn Ranch visit or the fairy-tale rewrite of history at the end. And I don't think that's the point. This movie is a vibe. It wants you to have a good time, and I was hooked.
There's barely a plot. It's 1977, and Cliff is drifting around the darkness of Hollywood, picking up odd jobs (the film mostly takes place at night), and the story we were sold doesn't really kick in until you're well over an hour in. In theory, that should be a problem. It isn't. You just want to be in this world, sitting in these bars and driving these streets with Booth. The movie doesn't aim for anything big, and that's a big part of its charm.
And yet, for all the hanging out, there's a constant sense of danger hovering over the movie. Somewhere in the night, two ruthless Filipino gangsters lurk, and the film reminds you a handful of times of their presence— they are the key to the whole puzzle. Every time they show up, the tension rises.
The ensemble is what carries it, and it plays like a '70s ensemble picture in the best way. Brad Pitt is great. He slips back into Cliff with ease: relaxed and funny, with that hint of menace still there. Elizabeth Debicki, whom I've been a fan of for years, is fantastic as Karen Crosby. Her flirtation with Pitt is playful, and it's the most fun the movie has. Scott Caan is a riot as a pint-sized star who insists on doing all his own stunts. I won't say who he reminds me of, but you'll figure it out within about five seconds. Then there's Peter Weller as Cliff's dad. He's rugged and gruff, but there's real warmth there, and it ends up being surprisingly moving.
You're going to hear a lot of critics say Fincher and Tarantino don't mesh. I'm sorry, but they kind of do here. Fincher loosens up. His frames are still very calculated, as they always are, but he's a great fit for the movie's slimy, underlit, sleazy-L.A. mood. When the violence comes, it's colder and more clinical than what Tarantino would've given us, and honestly, that works in the movie's favor. Mostly, though, Fincher gets out of the way and lets the script breathe.
And that script is all banter. Tarantino clearly loves these characters. He'd hang out with them forever, and for about two and a half hours, I was happy to let him. Watching it, I get why he didn't want to direct this as his tenth and final film. It's not really a statement. There's no grand farewell here, no summing up of a career. It's just fun filmmaking. It’s not a last movie.
Pauline Kael, who is mentioned in this movie, once said that movies so rarely rise to the level of great art that if we can't enjoy great trash, we have little reason to care about them at all. Debicki's Karen Crosby, a former film critic turned agent, a former Paulette, brings up that very idea, and she might as well be talking about ‘Cliff Booth.’ Is it trash? Not exactly. But it has everything that makes great trash fun. There’s swagger, sleaze, the total lack of interest in impressing you. Fincher and Tarantino know exactly what they're making here.
Unlike Tarantino’s other scripts, it’s not trying to be a masterpiece, but who knows? With time, maybe it will become one. But I'll say this, and I mean it: this is Fincher's best film since "Gone Girl." "Mank" and "The Killer" had their moments, but this is the first time in over a decade that he seems to be having a good time making something, and that fun is contagious. It's a hangout movie made by two of the best filmmakers alive, and (who are we kidding here?) that's more than enough.
So far, ‘Cliff Booth’ sits at 70 on Metacritic and 85% on Rotten Tomatoes. That’s not bad, right? Still, I think that shortchanges what is certainly one of the year’s best films.