Remember the first reactions? The ones calling this the "Rogue One" of the franchise? Yeah, about that.
The review embargo for "The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping" lifted Tuesday morning. As of this writing, the film sits at a 69% on Rotten Tomatoes, based on 62 reviews. Metacritic is less kind at 56, which lands squarely in "mixed or average" territory. Not a disaster, but a long way from what the social media funkos promised.
For context, here's how the franchise stacks up on Rotten Tomatoes: it sits above "The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes" (64%) but well behind "The Hunger Games" (85%) and "Catching Fire" (90%). In other words, Francis Lawrence's return is very mid.
Owen Gleiberman at Variety calls the film "meandering and more than a bit thin," though he still gives it a "fresh" rating and credits Lawrence's return to what he calls "Hunger Games Classic" style. The Guardian's Peter Bradshaw was far harsher. In a one-star review, he called the film "surreally boring" and took aim at the 158-minute runtime and the arena sequences, which he said weren't remotely scary.
My take is simple: I walked out of this movie at the halfway mark. I rarely do that. I was aghast at how far the glowing early reactions were from the quality of what I was seeing on screen. Now, before you attack me for giving up on the film, my reasoning was simple: either I spend 2.5 hours watching a film this ill-executed and dull, or I get back to what was a busy news day and post a handful of pieces for readers. I chose the latter. I'm not losing sleep over it, and I'll eventually finish the film, although I'm dreading it.
Does any of this matter for the box office? Probably not. Presales have been strong, the book is a phenomenon, and the core audience isn't checking Metacritic before buying tickets. It'll probably open to around $120M domestically.
Francis Lawrence directs, with Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie as screenwriters. Joseph Zada leads, backed by an impressive supporting cast that includes Ralph Fiennes, Elle Fanning, Jesse Plemons, Kieran Culkin, Maya Hawke, Glenn Close, Mckenna Grace and Lili Taylor. The film opens in theaters on November 20.
Remember the first reactions? The ones calling this the "Rogue One" of the franchise? Yeah, about that. The review embargo for "The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping" lifted Tuesday morning.