Here's a big endorsement for one of this year's Best Picture contenders at the Oscars.
MoMA honored Steven Spielberg at its annual film gala last Thursday night in Manhattan. Amid the festivities, Spielberg told The New York Times what he's been watching lately: Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim's three-hour Elizabeth Holmes mind-bender, "You Can See Everything."
It was one of the most extraordinary documentaries — if you can call it a documentary — that I've seen in a couple of decades. It was really groundbreaking. I'm a big fan.
"If you can call it a documentary." That's the line that jumps out, because it's the same fascinating debate that's been going on since the film's surprise Telluride premiere. Is it a doc? Is it a Fielder construction? Is it some hybrid nobody has a name for yet? Even Spielberg isn't sure, and he seems delighted by the result.
Spielberg had no reason to go to bat for an A24 doc. I've said since September that it has a real shot at becoming the first documentary ever nominated for Best Picture, and a Spielberg endorsement certainly won't hurt. When Steven talks, Academy members listen. Remember when he passionately championed "Green Book" back in 2018?
The main question is exactly what voters, especially the notoriously fickle documentary branch, will think of the film’s hybrid nature. That doc branch is notoriously purist, and have snubbed plenty of supposed locks over the years,” including “Won't You Be My Neighbor?" and "Apollo 11," so nothing is guaranteed.
Regardless, there aren't many Best Picture locks at the moment. There are maybe five at most: "The Odyssey," "La Bola Negra," "Project Hail Mary," "Wild Horse Nine" and "You Can See Everything." Not too far behind, and fighting it out for the final five spots, are “I Play Rocky,” “The Debut,” “The Invite,” “Obsession,” “Artificial,” “All of a Sudden,”and “Fjord.” Meanwhile, ‘Dune 3’ and ‘Cliff Booth’ have yet to premiere.
I was really taken by "Lights Out" when it came out 10 years ago, but Sandberg’s Hollywood stint kind of watered down his brand. He came back to the genre with last year's lackluster "Until Dawn," and now this.