TV Critics Poll — The Participants

Seth Abramovitch (The Hollywood Reporter)

Succession
Enlightened
Broad City
Twin Peaks: The Return
Stranger Things

Thelma Adams (AARP)

Spiral
Hannibal
Killing Eve
Fleabag
Mrs. Maisel

John Anderson (Freelance)

Stranger Things
Man In The High Castle
The Grand Tour
The Punisher
The Walking Dead

Erik Anderson (Awards Watch)

The Americans
BoJack Horseman
Crazy Ex-Girlfriend
Hannibal
The Leftovers

Charles Bright (Gold Derby)

Happy Endings
Twin Peaks: The Return
BoJack Horseman
Breaking Bad
Broad City

Christopher Bumbray (Joblo)

Breaking Bad
Mad Men
Succession
Game of Thrones
Mindhunter

Sarah D. Bunting (Tomato Nation)

American Crime Story
Atlanta
Better Call Saul
Rectify
The Good Fight

Ben Cahlamer (Phoenix Film Festival)

Game of Thrones
Mad Men
The Americans
Justified
Brooklyn Nine-Nine

Jonathan Caouette (Director)

Twin Peaks: The Return
The Leftovers
The Act
Jonestown: Terror In The Jungle
Homecoming

Chris Carpenter (Freelance)

The Walking Dead
The Handmaids Tale
The Good Place
Westworld
Stranger Things

Dylan Chuck (The Hollywood Reporter)

Breaking Bad
Game of Thrones
The Leftovers
Dexter
Better Call Saul

Nick Clement (Variety)

Mad Men
South Park
Breaking Bad
Chernobyl
Escape from Dannemora

Eric Deggans (NPR)

Breaking Bad
Atlanta
Game of Thrones
Veep
Justified

Nora Dominick (Buzzfeed)

Game of Thrones
Fleabag
Breaking Bad
Stranger Things
Veep

Michael Dunaway (Paste Magazine)

Breaking Bad
Mad Men
Eastbound and Down
Atlanta
Rectify

David Fear (Rolling Stone)

Fleabag
Hannibal
Legion
Orange Is the New Black
Twin Peaks: The Return

Daniel Fienberg (The Hollywood Reporter)

Mad Men
Parks & Recreation
Bojack Horseman
Breaking Bad
Rectify

Daniel Findler (Freelance)

The Leftovers
Terriers
Nathan For You
Pose
Boardwalk Empire

Bruce Fretts (The New York Times)

Boardwalk Empire
Breaking Bad
Justified
Mad Men
Veep

Natasha Gatian (Decadent Critic)

Hannibal
Bojack Horseman
Atlanta
Broad City
Game of Thrones
The Americans

Glenn Garvin (Reason Magazine)

The Americans
Homeland
The Night Of
The Deuce
American Crime Story: The People vs. OJ Simpson

John Griffiths (AARP)

30 Rock
Mad Men
The Good Wife
The Good Fight
The Americans

Will Harris (The AV Club)

Breaking Bad
Community
Veep
Parks & Recreation
Mad Men

Alison Herman (The Ringer)

The Leftovers
Halt and Catch Fire
BoJack Horseman
Twin Peaks: The Return
Fleabag

Stephen Hladik (The Film Stage)

Mad Men
The Leftovers
The Americans
Fleabag
Transparent

Matt Hoffman (Film School Rejects)

The Deuce
Mad Men
Enlightened
Olive Kitteridge
The Americans
The Leftovers

Drew Husband (Too Much Comedy)

Parks and Recreation
Breaking Bad
Fleabag
Hannibal
You're The Worst.

Hunter Ingram (Freelance)

The Leftovers
Parks and Recreation
Schitt’s Creek
American Crime Story: The People V. OJ Simpson
Enlightened

Dave Karger (TCM)

Mad Men
Fleabag
Big Little Lies
The Crown
House of Cards

Brandon Katz (Observer)

Breaking Bad
Mad Men
Game of Thrones
The Leftovers
The Americans

James Kleinmann (The Queer Review)

Twin Peaks: The Return
The Handmaid’s Tale
Fleabag
Killing Eve
Schitts Creek

Peter Knegt (CBC Arts)

The Leftovers
Fleabag
Bojack Horseman
Enlightened
Catastrophe

Proma Khosla (Mashable)

The Americans
Atlanta
Barry
Bob’s Burgers
Bojack Horseman

Amanda Kooser (C/Net)

Game of Thrones
Breaking Bad
Mad Men
The Walking Dead
Downton Abbey

Craig D. Lindsey (Nashville Scene)

Atlanta
Breaking Bad
Fleabag
Last Week Tonight with John Oliver
Twin Peaks: The Return

Rod Lurie (Director)

The Leftovers
Mad Men
Fleabag
The Good Place
Fargo

Jason Lynch (Adweek)

Mad Men
Breaking Bad
The Americans
The Leftovers
Parks and Recreation

Mekeisha Madden (Variety)

Breaking Bad
Atlanta
Game of Thrones
Black Mirror
The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel

Fred Melamed (Actor)

Madmen
Olive Kitteridge
The Crown
Casual
Breaking Bad

Pete Miesel (Freelance)

Breaking Bad
Better Call Saul
Russian Doll
Good Place
Documentary Now

Joey Moser (Awards Daily)

Fleabag
American Crime Story
Mad Men
Catastrophe
Black Mirror

Noel Murray (The AV Club)

Breaking Bad
Bob’s Burgers
The Leftovers
Brooklyn Nine-Nine
Game Of Thrones

Matt Neglia (Next Best Picture)

Game Of Thrones
Breaking Bad
The Leftovers
Bojack Horseman
Downton Abbey

Devin O’Leary (Weekly Alibi)

Mad Men
Breaking Bad
Game of Thrones
Parks & Recreation
Adventure Time

Rei Padla (DlMag)

Game of Thrones
Breaking Bad
The Walking Dead
Stranger Things
This Is Us

Matt Prigge (Metro)

Twin Peaks: The Return
BoJack Horseman
Veep
The Knick
Mad Men

Laura Prudom (IGN)

Fleabag
Jane the Virgin
The Good Wife
Game of Thrones
Atlanta

Aaron Pruner (Playboy)

Breaking Bad
Killing Eve
Justified
Barry
Anthony Bourdain: Parts Unknown

Claudia Puig (USA Today)

Handmaid’s Tale
Mad Men
Fleabag
Jane the Virgin
Veep

Mara Reinstein (US Weekly)

Breaking Bad
Mad Men
Girls
The Good Wife
Modern Family.

Melodie Daniel Rice (Film Inquiry)

Twin Peaks: The Return
Rectify
Breaking Bad
Enlightened
Nathan for You

Carrie Rickey (Philadelphia Inquirer)

Mad Men
The Crown
Russian Doll
The Komisky Method
Masters of Sex

Rene Rodriguez (Miami Herald)

Game of Thrones
Breaking Bad
Better Call Saul
Succession
Twin Peaks: The Return

Rubén Rosario (Miamiartzine)

Better Call Saul
Fleabag
Justified
Mad Men
Twin Peaks: The Return

Jordan Ruimy (World of Reel)

Breaking Bad
The Night Of …
Veep
The Leftovers
Better Call Saul

Nick Schager (Slant Magazine)

Mad Men
Breaking Bad
Justified
The Knick
Twin Peaks: The Return

Ian Schultz (Little White Lies)

Babylon Berlin
Mindhunter
True Detective (Only Season 1)
Twin Peaks: The Return
Barry

John Sellers (Thrillist)

Twin Peaks: The Return
Game of Thrones
Breaking Bad
Halt and Catch Fire
Difficult People

Alan Sepinwall (Rolling Stone)

The Leftovers
Parks and Recreation
Breaking Bad
Mad Men
BoJack Horseman

Tim Sika (KGO 810 AM)

Breaking Bad
Mad Men
The Handmaid’s Tale
Twin Peaks: The Return
Succession

Jeff Sneider (Collider)

Breaking Bad
American Crime Story x2
Fargo
Mindhunter
Chernobyl

David Sterritt (Christian Science Monitor)

Black Mirror
Game of Thrones
Mad Men
Sherlock
Veep

Sara Stewart (NY Post)

Fleabag
Better Things
The Good Place
Veep
Crazy Ex-Girlfriend

Sasha Stone (Awards Daily)

Succession
Mindhunter
Fleabag
Mad Men
Breaking Bad

Brian Tallerico (RogerEbert)

The Americans
Atlanta
Better Call Saul
Hannibal
The Leftovers

Jonathan Teigland (Freelance)

Mad Men
Fleabag
Handmaid’s Tale
Breaking Bad
Schitt’s Creek

Brian Truitt (USA Today)

Game of Thrones
The Leftovers
Black Mirror
Sherlock
The Good Wife

Carlos Valladares (SF Chronicle)

Twin Peaks: The Return
Olive Kitteridge
Parks and Recreation
Breaking Bad
America to Me

Eric Wakulski (Joblo)

Breaking Bad
Black Mirror
Fargo
Key and Peele
Succession

Glenn Whipp (Los Angeles Daily News)

Atlanta
Broad City
Twin Peaks: The Return
Fleabag
Key & Peele

Pawel Wieszczecinski (Kinoscope)

Twin Peaks: The Return
True Dedective
Breaking Bad
Ozark
Better Call Saul

Matthew Wilder (Screenwriter/Director)

Enlightened
The Girlfriend Experience
The Leftovers
The Knick
Better Call Saul

Susan Wloszczyna (Gold Derby)

Fleabag
The Good Wife
Mad Men
American Crime Story: The People vs. O.J, Simpson
The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel

Craig Younkin (Freelance)

Breaking Bad
The Americans
Sons of Anarchy
The Good Place
Veep

IndieWire

The Leftovers
Fleabag
Breaking Bad
Bojack Horseman
Hannibal

Paste Magazine

Breaking Bad
Mad Men
The Americans
Planet Earth
Fleabag

TV Guide

Atlanta
Justified
The Leftovers
Veep
The Americans

The Guardian

Breaking Bad
Mad Men
Game of Thrones
Fleabag
Atlanta

TV Line

The Americans
Better Call Saul
Breaking Bad
Fargo
Game of Thrones
The Good Wife
Justified
Mad Men
Rectify