Last year the BBC polled hundreds of film critics, scholars, writers, journalists etc. and asked the same question. The results from that poll were a little more to my liking. It's been 17 years since the start of the new century and we've had plenty of great films. If I had to pick these would be on it:
(1) "Mulholland Drive," Dir. David Lynch
(2) "Tree of Life," Dir. Terrence Malick
(5) "Children of Men," Dir. Alfonso Cuaron
(6) "No Country For Old Men," Dir. Joel Coen
(7) "Zodiac," Dir. David Fincher
(8) "Margaret," Dir. Kenneth Lonergan
(9) "A Separation," Dir. Asghar Farhadi
(16) "Upstream Color," Dir. Shane Carruth
(17) "Memento," Dir. Christopher Nolan
(18) "Lost in Translation," Sofia Coppola
(23) "Oldboy," Dir. Park Chan-Wook
(24) "WALL-E," Dir. Andrew Stanton
(25) "The 25th Hour," Dir. Spike Lee
(26) "The Lord of the Rings," Dir. Peter Jackson
(29) "Pan's Labyrinth," Dir. Guillermo Del Toro
(30) "4 Month, 3 Weeks and 2 Days," Dir. Cristi Mungiu
Here is a little something I wrote on Facebook concerning Mulholland Drive:
"How about because it's the kind of film that is exactly about why we go to the movies in the first place. A dreamy, surreal, almost unexplained work of art. It intrigues you, frustrates you and passionately reaffirms your undying love for the movies. David Lynch dared us to get inside his bag of magic tricks and the epiphanic result felt like a religious re-awakening. In Scorsese's "Hugo" George Melies says concerning the cinema: "If you've ever wondered where your dreams come from, look around this is where they're made. Come and dream with me." Lynch invited us to dream with him as well back in 2001 and we haven't been able to shake it ever since.
This is a significant update for a project that has been stuck in development for years, and comes roughly a year after Brolin said “Sicario 3” was a maybe.