‘Rogue One’ Remains Disney’s Best Star Wars Movie — Gareth Edwards Disagrees

It’s been nearly a decade since Disney’s Star Wars era began with sky-high expectations and billions in merchandise. And yet, amidst a run of nostalgia-mining (“The Force Awakens”), divisive fan-baiting (‘The Last Jedi’), and outright disasters (‘The Rise of Skywalker,’ ‘Solo’), only “Rogue One” truly feels like a singular moment — the one installment that’s aged like fine wine, not blue milk.

Released in 2016, Gareth Edwards’ “Rogue One: A Star Wars Story” was born out of troubled production. Tony Gilroy was brought in for heavy reshoots after Edwards’ initial cut reportedly didn’t meet Disney's tonal expectations. And yet, the film defied the odds: dark, morally grey, grounded in the grit of rebellion, and capped by one of the most beautiful endings in the franchise — a climax that actually meant something.

Now, in a new interview with Business Insider, director Edwards says he’s happy to let that moment stand alone. When asked if he’d ever return to the Star Wars sandbox, Edwards responded with a polite but clear: “I feel like I’ve said everything I wanted to say with that movie.” Can you blame him?

Edwards was quick to downplay the widely circulated consensus that ‘Rogue One’ is the best Star Wars film of the Disney era. “I don’t agree with it, but I appreciate it,” he said. “I’m very grateful that people say nice things.”

Edwards’ reluctance highlights something crucial: making a good Star Wars film under the Disney machine is a near-impossible task. Even when the final product works, as ‘Rogue One’ does, it’s often in spite of the process, not because of it. Edwards’ vision was essentially reshaped by Gilroy, who would later expand the film’s world even further in the much-lauded “Andor” series. But that creative instability — directors being replaced, visions clashing — has become a recurring theme in Lucasfilm's Disney era.

What makes ‘Rogue One’ work is precisely what most of the other Disney Star Wars entries avoid: finality, consequence, restraint. It’s a war movie set in a galaxy where nobody is safe and ideology isn’t cleanly divided into light and dark. The film gets bleaker the closer it gets to ‘A New Hope,’ until it hands off the baton — quite literally — in that memorable hallway scene with Vader.

In hindsight, ‘Rogue One,’ which was beautifully shot by Greig Fraser, might be the only film from this era that will still be discussed in 10, 20 years with the same reverence given to Lucas' originals. That it came together in such a messy way, and that even its director wants nothing to do with the current state of the franchise, says a lot about the uphill battle of making anything worthwhile in the IP era.

Sometimes a miracle slips through the machine. ‘Rogue One’ was that miracle for Disney. And we may not see another like it for a long time.