It’s hard to overstate just how much Ridley Scott and Russell Crowe’s “Gladiator” arrived at the perfect moment — a time when original storytelling still thrived on the big screen. I remember walking in completely blind, having not seen a trailer, and leaving stunned by the old-school spectacle and craftsmanship. The film would go on to win Best Picture, earn Crowe a Best Actor Oscar, and cement itself as a mainstream modern classic of the 21st century.
That said, can we all agree that Scott’s “Gladiator 2” was a total dud? Paul Mescal was miscast, the script meandered, and it lacked the emotional and dramatic pull of the original. For some reason, Scott believes it’s the best film he’s ever made — a bold claim, to say the least. Now, Crowe is speaking out, and his criticism is justified.
“I think the recent sequel that, you know, we don’t have to name out loud [referring to “Gladiator 2”], is a really unfortunate example of even the people in that engine room not actually understanding what made the first one special,” Crowe told Triple J (via The Playlist). “It wasn’t the pomp. It wasn’t the circumstance. It wasn’t the action. It was the moral core.”
A major point of contention for Crowe is the revelation that Paul Mescal’s Lucius is portrayed as the illegitimate son of Maximus — something never hinted at in the original film. Crowe feels this twist undermines the character’s integrity and robs the sequel of the depth that made the first film resonate.
He also struggles with the idea of Maximus, who thrived on loyalty, having an affair with Connie Nielsen’s Lucilla — the daughter of Emperor Marcus Aurelius — when his “moral code” was the very reason he sought vengeance for his wife and son. “Makes no sense to me,” Crowe states.
He even recalls having to fight Scott during the making of the original to keep Maximus’ moral compass intact. “The thing is, there was a daily fight on that set. It was a daily fight to keep that moral core of the character,” he said. “The amount of times they suggested sex scenes and stuff like that for Maximus, it’s like you’re taking away his power. So you’re saying at the same time he had this relationship with his wife, he was f***ing this other girl? What are you talking about? It’s crazy.”
Despite the sequel being a mess, it still found a market — largely thanks to the ‘Gladiator’ brand. Crowe wasn’t involved, yet “Gladiator 2” earned $462 worldwide, despite underwhelming reactions from audiences and critics alike.
And now, Scott is reportedly threatening a “Gladiator 3,” with a script already in the works. Whether audiences will be duped again remains to be seen.